Rochdale’s education chief compiled damning report on ‘dereliction of duty’ at school
By Nick Fielding | 11 September 2013
Members of the teaching staff at Knowl View were accused of a “dereliction of duty” in a report by Rochdale’s education chief.
Diana Cavanagh, director of education at Rochdale metropolitan borough council, wrote the paper, which is part of a confidential cache of official documents that detail abuse of boys at Knowl View school.
It came in response to members of school staff who wrote a joint letter in April 1992 demanding a “full and immediate inquiry” into Knowl View. Cyril Smith, former Liberal MP, was a governor there for 34 of the 36 years that it was open.
The letter made clear, in light of a damning report on Knowl View in February 1992 by a consultant clinical psychologist, Valerie Mellor, staff members’ “total unease” about “various incidents” that had been “left unresolved”.
“Boys were also conscious of a considerable level of sexual activity among some staff on the Knowl View premises”
– Diana Cavanagh, director of education, Rochdale council, writing in a report
Cavanagh wrote: “The responsibilities of teaching staff in a residential special school cannot begin and end with the teaching day.”
“Statements from staff reflect a lack of commitment to a whole-school approach,” adding, “This response approaches dereliction of duty.”
“The culture of many lessons and activities has been described as ‘macho’. Sometimes this spilled over into violence and aggression, including a physical assault by one teacher on a pupil.
“It can be assumed that this culture reinforced and supported the bullying tactics of some pupils towards other pupils. Coercion and bullying were a feature of some of the sexual activities in [one] unit.”
The report also strongly criticised care staff. It said that boys aged 11 to 13 at one unit of the school “were involved in homosexual activities at the Smith Street toilets”, adding, “Those supervising the boys in the evenings appeared either not to notice that they were missing, or not to communicate their observations.”
The report made similar comments about care staff who were responsible for boys aged 15 to 17 at another unit, where a nearby resident, Rodney Hilton, was let into the school building by boys and carried out sexual abuse. Hilton was convicted in 1991.
“Information about homosexual activity at the Smith Street toilets between boys (some from Knowl View) and adult males was known to police and social services.”
“There is no record of this information being passed on to the education service – either the education psychological service, the school or the department.”
There were several factors that led to the failure of staff to report on disturbing incidents, she wrote. For example, she said: “Staff on duty were engaged in activities that made it unlikely that they would be alert to what was happening in the dormitories. It has been stated that some of these on-site activities were sexual.”
She added: “Boys were also conscious of a considerable level of sexual activity among some staff on the Knowl View premises, and this may have inhibited proper discussions between staff and boys.”
“The governors did not monitor the situation, or were fobbed off with little real information.”
She concluded: “There was a catastrophic failure of leadership at the school, which allowed poor practice and irresponsible behaviour to flourish under the guise of different philosophies.”
“There was a general refusal by staff to take ownership for the well-being of the whole institution, and to develop whole-school policies for curriculum and care.”
However, she wrote: “There is insufficient evidence to prove culpable neglect, fraud or incompetence by any single member of staff.”
She condemned her own department and other agencies for their failings over Knowl View, saying: “There was a calamitous failure by outside agencies and the [local education authority] to communicate all appropriate information to the head.”
Since May 1991, she said, “determined efforts” were being made to turn the school round.
But, by 1995, within three years of Cavanagh’s report, the school was closed.
Simon Danczuk, Labour MP for Rochdale, Smith’s former constituency, told Exaro: “The full story about Knowl View has to be told. This is a shocking chapter in Rochdale’s history, which saw a generation of young boys’ lives destroyed.
“As upsetting as it is, it is important that their stories are heard, and doubly important that the public is given assurances that none of the staff that oversaw this terrible abuse is still caring for children.”
Related Stories
- Priest and ex-manager of Richmond children’s home in court | 338 words
- Revealed: how Cyril Smith denied paedophile claims to police | 720 words
- Cyril Smith told detectives: I never behaved in any indecent way | 673 words
- ‘Operation Fernbridge’ arrests ex-manager of Elm Guest House | 856 words
- Church of England considers ‘commission’ on child sex abuse | 695 words
- Ofsted forces private school to close over sexual abuse of pupils | 700 words
- Exaro’s video shows ‘Fairbank’ arrest of Tory MP’s half-brother | 386 words
- Met’s ‘Operation Fairbank’ arrests half-brother of top Tory MP | 801 words
- Kenneth Clarke wrongly accused of indecently assaulting boy | 695 words
- How I helped police clear Kenneth Clarke of ‘sex assault’ smear | 603 words
- MBE for head of project helping sex victims, but funding is axed | 695 words
- Labour urges re-think on reporting by schools of abuse claims | 706 words
- Michael Gove blocks move to force schools to report sex abuse | 714 words
- Met’s ‘Operation Fernbridge’ is ‘going well’, says Boris Johnson | 724 words
- Met investigates Catholic order’s schools over child sex abuse | 784 words
- Operation Torva: ex-pupil joined police and triggered Met probe | 780 words
- MoD policy on claims of child sex abuse at schools ‘stuns’ MPs | 829 words
- Police abandon probe into Cyril Smith’s sexual abuse of boys | 854 words
- Elm Guest House linked to ‘Britain’s biggest child sex racket’ | 723 words
- Ex-Richmond boss Louis Minster denies being… Louis Minster | 753 words
- Scene pictured from children’s home in Met’s paedophile case | 688 words
- Richmond files reveal failure to pursue claim of child sex abuse | 679 words
- Met investigates police watchdog over Richmond ‘paedo ring’ | 665 words
- Met’s paedophile unit starts investigating Catholic Church in UK | 731 words
- Police commander overseeing ‘Operation Yewtree’ quits Met | 729 words
- Police seek Asbo-style orders against suspected paedophiles | 720 words
- Child sex abuse: groups offering support services face closure | 719 words
- Police re-open files on child sex abuse at Kincora boys’ home | 660 words
- Witnesses in ‘Operation Fernbridge’ plead for support service | 710 words
- Analysis: we must change how society tackles child sex abuse | 751 words
- Richmond council ‘was alerted to allegations of child sex abuse’ | 707 words
- Police gave council advance warning of raid on Elm Guest House | 551 words
- Met paedophile unit prepares to arrest ex-Tory cabinet minister | 645 words
- Met detectives told of Jimmy Savile’s link to Elm Guest House | 576 words
- Analysis: public should know truth about VIP paedophile ring | 582 words
- Co-manager of guest house in police probe plans to leave UK | 648 words
- Claims of child sex abuse haunted Richmond boss for 30 years | 664 words
- Police examine sacking of Richmond’s head of social services | 719 words
- Councillors give contrasting reasons for Louis Minster’s sacking | 720 words
- Richmond’s ex-head of social services ‘unaware’ of ‘paedo ring’ | 626 words
- Exaro’s pictures show first arrest in ‘Operation Fernbridge’ | 614 words
- ‘Operation Fernbridge’ makes first arrests in paedophile probe | 843 words
- Two managers of children’s home named in VIP paedo probe | 717 words
- Files reveal who turned Elm Guest House into paedo brothel | 726 words
- Richmond council made ‘hush payment’ to victim of sex abuse | 719 words
- Police chief warns VIP paedophiles: look over your shoulder | 728 words
- Tory group recommended guest house in Met’s paedo probe | 725 words
- Police investigate Richmond council over ‘VIP paedophile ring’ | 726 words
- Detectives set up 30 operations into ‘child sex abuse by groups’ | 721 words
- Police operations into ‘child sex abuse by groups’ – Exaro’s list | 1302 words
- Found: co-manager of guest house at centre of police probe | 731 words
- Met turns ‘Operation Fairbank’ into full criminal investigation | 762 words
- ‘Operation Fairbank’ carries out raid to seize files naming MPs | 636 words
- How exposure of high-profile abusers impacts care for children | 709 words
- Revealed: diaries and receipts for guest house in police probe | 754 words
- Locals spoke of ‘the activities’ at guest house in police probe | 758 words
- MPs and judges visited Elm Guest House, coroner’s court told | 721 words
- Detectives who must peer into disturbing case of child abuse | 735 words
- Police investigate top Tories over ‘child abuse at guest house’ | 725 words
- Police ‘twice failed to probe paedophile ring at guest house’ | 747 words
- Analysis: why media must still investigate claims of child abuse | 757 words
- Audio: investigative journalism’s future after Newsnight fiasco | 115 words
- Investigations, not witch-hunts: David Hencke on BBC R4 Today | 234 words