Top politician robustly rejected claims of sexual abuse of boys in care, police files show
By Nick Fielding | 16 July 2013
Former Liberal MP Sir Cyril Smith made a robust denial to detectives that he sexually abused boys at a children’s home, Exaro can reveal.
A document obtained by Exaro reveals that Smith staunchly defended his behaviour when detectives asked him to comment about allegations that he was a paedophile who abused at least eight boys at Cambridge House hostel, the privately-run care home that he helped to establish in Rochdale.
He began by telling investigating officers: “I am not prepared to make a statement at this stage as to the allegations made by the eight boys.”
But he then told detectives: “I am, however, prepared to say this. I was active in the running and administration of the hostel.”
“The object was to help the under-privileged and deprived boys of over school leaving age, many of whom had social, domestic, health and other problems, and to get them settled continuous and productive employment. In respect of some of the boys, we were faced with difficult problems of discipline arising from general misconduct, [redacted] and work shyness.”
Smith was speaking to detectives in February 1970 after Lancashire Police launched the investigation the previous year.
Several young men alleged that Smith had administered corporal punishment and fondled them while they were residents at Cambridge House. Smith was then a councillor and due to stand for election as an MP in June 1970.
The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) disclosed to Exaro under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) the police document that records Smith’s comments. Some parts are redacted.
A previous FOIA disclosure revealed that Smith tried to browbeat the lead officer by calling in at a police station in January 1970, demanding to know about the accusations.
Smith refused on legal advice to make a formal statement. But he was concerned, he said, that if he were charged it would prevent him from standing as a candidate in the general election. He returned to the station a month later with what appear to be carefully prepared comments.
Detectives record Smith as saying: “I never heard a single complaint as to any conduct of mine being made by any boy or any committee member or anybody else, and I am quite astounded at these present complaints made so long after the alleged events.
“I am in the position to call very many witnesses not only as to my general integrity, which has never heretofore been questioned, but also as to the unfailing help and support that I have always been known to give to my fellow townsfolk in general, and the youth of the town in particular.”
“Personally, I would just like to point out that the mere existence of these allegations, if they become known, may be damaging to my public and private career. But, at the same time, I wish to state most emphatically that I have never behaved in any indecent way towards any of these boys, but have done my best to help them at a difficult stage in their lives.”
Exaro today publishes the full text of Smith’s comments as recorded by Lancashire Police and disclosed by the CPS.
Police officers took statements from at least seven boys who had stayed at Cambridge House and at least one other who had never lived there.
According to affidavits given by seven former residents, Smith carried out beatings and medical “examinations”, often in the so-called “Quiet Room”.
The director of public prosecutions decided in 1970 against prosecuting Smith.
The CPS admitted last November that this decision, together with refusals to prosecute Smith in 1998 and 1999, would not have been made on the same basis today.
The evidence is that Smith also abused young boys in the 1980’s and 1990’s at Knowl View special school, where he was the governors’ chairman.
Greater Manchester Police (GMP), which covers Rochdale since a reorganisation in 1974, promised in November that it would re-investigate Smith, who died in 2010.
But Exaro revealed in May that GMP was dropping its investigation into Smith’s sexual abuse of boys.
The disclosure prompted GMP to announce an investigation into three complaints of sexual abuse at Knowl View school dating back to the 1970’s, although none is against Smith specifically.
Cyril Smith told detectives: I never behaved in any indecent way | 673 words
- ‘Operation Fernbridge’ arrests ex-manager of Elm Guest House | 856 words
- Church of England considers ‘commission’ on child sex abuse | 695 words
- Ofsted forces private school to close over sexual abuse of pupils | 700 words
- Exaro’s video shows ‘Fairbank’ arrest of Tory MP’s half-brother | 386 words
- Met’s ‘Operation Fairbank’ arrests half-brother of top Tory MP | 801 words
- Kenneth Clarke wrongly accused of indecently assaulting boy | 695 words
- How I helped police clear Kenneth Clarke of ‘sex assault’ smear | 603 words
- MBE for head of project helping sex victims, but funding is axed | 695 words
- Labour urges re-think on reporting by schools of abuse claims | 706 words
- Michael Gove blocks move to force schools to report sex abuse | 714 words
- Met’s ‘Operation Fernbridge’ is ‘going well’, says Boris Johnson | 724 words
- Met investigates Catholic order’s schools over child sex abuse | 784 words
- Operation Torva: ex-pupil joined police and triggered Met probe | 780 words
- MoD policy on claims of child sex abuse at schools ‘stuns’ MPs | 829 words
- Police abandon probe into Cyril Smith’s sexual abuse of boys | 854 words
- Elm Guest House linked to ‘Britain’s biggest child sex racket’ | 723 words
- Ex-Richmond boss Louis Minster denies being… Louis Minster | 753 words
- Scene pictured from children’s home in Met’s paedophile case | 688 words
- Richmond files reveal failure to pursue claim of child sex abuse | 679 words
- Met investigates police watchdog over Richmond ‘paedo ring’ | 665 words
- Met’s paedophile unit starts investigating Catholic Church in UK | 731 words
- Police commander overseeing ‘Operation Yewtree’ quits Met | 729 words
- Police seek Asbo-style orders against suspected paedophiles | 720 words
- Child sex abuse: groups offering support services face closure | 719 words
- Police re-open files on child sex abuse at Kincora boys’ home | 660 words
- Witnesses in ‘Operation Fernbridge’ plead for support service | 710 words
- Analysis: we must change how society tackles child sex abuse | 751 words
- Richmond council ‘was alerted to allegations of child sex abuse’ | 707 words
- Police gave council advance warning of raid on Elm Guest House | 551 words
- Met paedophile unit prepares to arrest ex-Tory cabinet minister | 645 words
- Met detectives told of Jimmy Savile’s link to Elm Guest House | 576 words
- Analysis: public should know truth about VIP paedophile ring | 582 words
- Co-manager of guest house in police probe plans to leave UK | 648 words
- Claims of child sex abuse haunted Richmond boss for 30 years | 664 words
- Councillors give contrasting reasons for Louis Minster’s sacking | 720 words
- Richmond’s ex-head of social services ‘unaware’ of ‘paedo ring’ | 626 words
- Exaro’s pictures show first arrest in ‘Operation Fernbridge’ | 614 words
- ‘Operation Fernbridge’ makes first arrests in paedophile probe | 843 words
- Two managers of children’s home named in VIP paedo probe | 717 words
- Files reveal who turned Elm Guest House into paedo brothel | 726 words
- Richmond council made ‘hush payment’ to victim of sex abuse | 719 words
- Police chief warns VIP paedophiles: look over your shoulder | 728 words
- Tory group recommended guest house in Met’s paedo probe | 725 words
- Police investigate Richmond council over ‘VIP paedophile ring’ | 726 words
- Detectives set up 30 operations into ‘child sex abuse by groups’ | 721 words
- Police operations into ‘child sex abuse by groups’ – Exaro’s list | 1302 words
- Found: co-manager of guest house at centre of police probe | 731 words
- Met turns ‘Operation Fairbank’ into full criminal investigation | 762 words
- ‘Operation Fairbank’ carries out raid to seize files naming MPs | 636 words
- How exposure of high-profile abusers impacts care for children | 709 words
- Revealed: diaries and receipts for guest house in police probe | 754 words
- Locals spoke of ‘the activities’ at guest house in police probe | 758 words
- MPs and judges visited Elm Guest House, coroner’s court told | 721 words
- Detectives who must peer into disturbing case of child abuse | 735 words
- Police investigate top Tories over ‘child abuse at guest house’ | 725 words
- Police ‘twice failed to probe paedophile ring at guest house’ | 747 words
- Analysis: why media must still investigate claims of child abuse | 757 words
- Audio: investigative journalism’s future after Newsnight fiasco | 115 words
- Investigations, not witch-hunts: David Hencke on BBC R4 Today | 234 words